Taxes

Since he announced in candidacy in March, Brown has promised repeatedly that he would not raise taxes without a vote of the people – a view that has not come without controversy, even from members of his own party.
But he has also decried a number of tax breaks proposed by Meg Whitman, arguing that they are infeasible given the state’s current economic condition. Brown has said repeatedly that he would not cut the state’s capital gains tax, which taxes assets like stock holdings, calling it a break for the rich.
Though he has frequently spoken out against the targeted tax breaks proposed by Whitman, Brown said in a July interview with CNBC’s Lawrence Kudlow that lowering marginal tax rates across the board could be “a very fine plan” but acknowledged a need to mind the state’s $19 billion budget deficit.
He has also voiced support for film industry tax breaks and tax credits for companies that hire new workers. And he has talked about diversifying the state's tax base to reduce its dependence on income taxes.
In a June interview with CNBC’s Jane Wellls Brown hinted at support for taxes on carbon and pollution as a means of creating incentives: “The key to taxes is what you what less of, you tax. What you want more of, you reduce taxes. And we want more jobs. We want more investment. We want less burning of carbon, we want less pollution, less toxins. And that sends the message of how we restructure the code.”
Key statements
Jerry Brown
/
Aug. 10, 2010All right, No. 1, unlike Mrs. Whitman I would not cut the capital gains tax which will take five billion dollars away from state government, our from our schools, from our police and fire departments. She wants to give a gigantic tax break, most of which will go to wealthiest people in our state. So that's what I won't do.
Source: San Francisco ChronicleTags: Taxes, Specific policy point or details
Jerry Brown
/
Aug. 8, 2010Brown also says he would consider tax breaks to encourage the creation of manufacturing jobs and calls for the creation of a strike team to attract and retain jobs.
Source: Los Angeles TimesTags: Jobs, Taxes, Policy or issue position
Jerry Brown
/
Aug. 3, 2010Brown responded that unlike his GOP opponent Meg Whitman, he wouldn't cut the capital gains tax, which would cut $5 billion from the budget. Then he said, to "begin with I would cut back the governor's expenses, like the private jet, mansion, and things considered luxuries."
Source: San Francisco ChronicleTags: Budget, Taxes, Specific policy point or details
Jerry Brown
/
July 16, 2010Kudlow: Why aren't you out there pounding on lower taxes because the state's not competitive anymore? Where are you on this stuff? Jerry Brown: She's not talking about an overall lower marginal tax rate, she has a lot of little, picky, little tax break for this group and a little tax break for that group. If you want to restructure the track system, and lower the marginal rates and spread out the base, that could be a very fine plan. But it's going to take a process. You're not going get it by a little pamphlet. And you've also got to deal with the fact that we've got a $19 billion deficit. And you're going to have to go over each department and start cutting this thing back in the best way you can. It isn't just snapping your fingers, and saying five tax breaks in a pamphlet.
Source: CNBCTags: Budget, Taxes, Candidate attack, Policy or issue position
Jerry Brown
/
July 16, 2010When I was governor last time, Proposition 13 came along, and yes, I opposed it, but when I got there, I rolled up my sleeves, and I not only made 13 work, but I bailed out the local governments so we could protect the schools and the fire and the police. And Howard Jarvis himself said I did a hell of a job. But I went beyond that. I supported a limit on state spending that a Republican governor later took off. And No. 2, we cut the income tax by $5 billion. I got rid of the inventory tax. And in a confrontation where the state employees wanted pay raises they couldn't afford, I vetoed those pay raises, not once, but twice. No other governor's done that. I've got a record of innovation, and a record of frugality, and a record of honesty and telling the truth. And I got a plan, right now.
Source: CNBCTags: Taxes, Assertion of fact, Policy or issue position
Jerry Brown
/
June 30, 2010Host: What will you do to keep film production from leaving California? Jerry Brown: We're going to give some tax breaks, and I'd like to give more, but we're in the hole by so much. And if we can find a way to target help, I certainly want to do that because we have to keep our key industries. High-tech, movies, agriculture, the port operation to the Pacific. Those are the keys and we have to make sure we don't lose them and we have to give them some extra help, I'm for it.
Source: KTTV-FOX (Los Angeles)Tags: Jobs, Taxes, Policy or issue position
Jerry Brown
/
June 30, 2010Jane Wells: Do you support reforming the tax code in the way that has been suggested by the state commission? Jerry Brown: Not necessarily, the way they did it, but that ought to be on the table. Can we create a more efficient tax system? Spreading the base, lowering some of the rates. Making it more reliable and not penalizing growth. The key to taxes is what you what less of, you tax. What you want more of, you reduce taxes. And we want more jobs. We want more investment. We want less burning of carbon, we want less pollution, less toxins. And that sends the message of how we restructure the code.
Source: CNBCTags: Business, Taxes, Specific policy point or details
Jerry Brown
/
June 30, 2010Host: How are we going to handle education? Jerry Brown: Well, the first thing we're not going to do is what Mrs. Whitman wants to do, which is to cut taxes on the very wealthiest people. She wants to take $5 billion from the capital gains tax and give it back to those people. That'll put a big hole in education. Schools need more money, not less. And going forward, I've said no taxes, unless the people themselves vote for them.
Source: KTTV-FOX (Los Angeles)Tags: Education, Taxes, Assertion of fact, Candidate attack, Policy or issue position
Jerry Brown
/
June 16, 2010KTVU asked Brown if he would consider changing Prop 13. "My thoughts on prop 13? Look. Next to the ten commandments and the bill of rights, I can't think of a better expression of human wisdom," Brown said.
Source: KTVU (FOX San Francisco)Tags: Taxes, Quotable, Specific policy point or details
Jerry Brown
/
June 1, 2010So could Ms. Whitman expect a state income tax increase if you become governor? No, I think the income tax is contributing an excessive amount to the state budget. When I was governor, the income tax was lower than the sales tax. It was about 33 percent of the general fund. Now it’s 55 percent. It’s far too unstable, and the tax base has to be broader than it is today. No, California taxes are very high on high-wealth individuals. They’re higher than they are in the rest of the country [except for Hawaii and Oregon]. If you make California such a high-tax state, you’re going to deter investment, and you’re going to deter people from wanting to live here. I mean, we’re in a competitive world. We can create a little island called California. If Arizona, Nevada, Oregon, Washington, and Texas all get to have less taxes, and if that’s where all of our business goes, we’re going to have even more of a problem than we do now. It’s really a loser to follow that path.
Source: Los Angeles MagazineTags: Budget, Taxes, Policy or issue position
Jerry Brown
/
March 29, 2010Second, in this time of recession when people are financially strapped, there will be no new taxes unless you the people vote for them.
Source: Jerry Brown campaignTags: Economy, Taxes, Promise

The centerpiece of Meg Whitman’s tax plan are a series of targeted cuts to various tax programs: the capital gains tax, which applies largely to stock holdings; sales taxes on manufacturing equipment; and an $800 fee on starting limited liability corporations, which her campaign refers to as a “startup tax.”
Her rationale has followed the convention that cutting taxes will spur growth by reducing the cost of doing business. Her budget plan calls for that additional growth to offset upwards of $5 billion of the state’s budget deficit and assumes tax cuts will help cause companies to hire 2 million workers by 2014.
Ideologically, Whitman supports the tax cuts enacted under President Bush in 2001 and 2003. Much of the rhetoric surrounding the cuts focuses on top income earners, but they’re not the only ones on the hook. This article explains how you would be affected, so you can get a better sense of her position.
Whitman has signed a pledge not to raise taxes but waffled slightly in June, when asked whether even an extreme natural disaster would be reason to levy new taxes for recovery efforts. She was caught off guard by the question and said she would not want to rule out taxes in such a situation, causing a minor stir.
In addition to cuts, Whitman has also proposed a series of tax credits: $10,000 for new homebuyers; credits to encourage water conservation; an expansion of the credit businesses receive on research and development activities; and a credit for companies that hire workers into green tech positions.
She philosophically supports cuts to statewide income and sales tax rates but said that would not happen until the economy recovers.
Key statements
Meg Whitman
/
Aug. 9, 2010Meg Whitman: You're right, Jerry Brown has no plan, and I have got a very detailed plan around those important priorities, but let's take jobs because it's the most important. I want to do some targeted tax cuts to get hire, to get hiring going again, for example, I want to eliminate the factory tax. I don't know if you know, but we are one of only three states that taxes manufacturing equipment, which is a disincentive to manufacture here. I want to streamline regulation. Regulation is strangling businesses of all sizes, and then I want to compete for jobs. You know, we lose jobs to Arizona, Colorado, Texas, Utah, and I want to have a terrific economic development team. You will not find a more staunch supporter of small business than me.
Source: KSWB (Fox 5-San Diego)Tags: Business, Jobs, Taxes, Policy or issue position, Specific policy point or details
Meg Whitman
/
July 28, 2010Host: Should Pres. Obama allow the Bush tax cuts to expire? Whitman: I don't think he should allow the Bush tax cuts to expire. We should not be raising taxes on anyone and any small businesses right now. We have a very fragile economy, as you know. And my view is let's not raise taxes, let's let this economy begin to recover. And I am against new taxes on Americans. We are overtaxed, the government is too big. We've got to live within our means, and my view is we don't actually have a revenue problem. We have a spending problem of epic proportions, particularly in California.
Source: San Francisco ChronicleTags: Economy, Taxes, Policy or issue position
Meg Whitman
/
July 16, 2010Kudlow: Are you still planning to eliminate the state capital gains tax, which has always been a job killer? Meg Whitman: I am. That is one of the key elements of my proposal, because we compete with other states who have no state capital gains tax, or rates that are half of Californians. And if we are going to continue being the innovation hub of America and the world, that's a very important element of my tax plan.
Source: CNBCTags: Business, Jobs, Taxes, Specific policy point or details
Meg Whitman
/
June 30, 2010At a campaign stop Tuesday in Roseville, Whitman was asked whether she would consider raising taxes if a natural disaster, such as an earthquake, rocked the state. There is some precedent: After the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, California levied a temporary quarter-cent sales tax for quake relief. She replied: "In a natural disaster, gosh, that's hard to predict. I mean if there was literally an 8.0 earthquake here and we had no way out, gosh, certainly, I wouldn't want to necessarily rule that out. But under normal set of circumstances, I think raising taxes on businesses and individuals is exactly the wrong thing to do."
Source: Los Angeles TimesTags: Taxes, Specific policy point or details
Meg Whitman
/
May 25, 2010I want to eliminate what I call the start-up tax. Before you do anything to start a new business you have got to pay the state an $800 LLC fee. I want to eliminate the state capital gains tax. We are one of a handful of states around us that has a very high state capital gains tax. I want to increase the R&D tax credit from 15 percent to 20 percent. That will give employers the confidence to hire.
Source: The Kudlow Report (CNBC)Tags: Business, Economy, Taxes, Specific policy point or details
Meg Whitman
/
May 25, 2010Kudlow: Is there a chance for marginal tax rate relief? Whitman: There is, but it's going to take a little bit of time. The truth is we cannot afford a 10 percent across the board tax cut right now. It's totally unrealistic given that we have got a $20 billion budget deficit and an unrealistic plan is an irresponsible plan. It will only serve to increase the debt load on California. We are already carrying the highest debt load we have ever had, $53 billion in debt in California. Next year just to service the debt will be $7.1 billion, nearly 10 percent of the general fund. So it's unrealistic right now. So ultimately, let's get people to work, cut $15 billion of spending out of the budget and then let's turbo charge the economy by making sure that we can then put in place an across the board tax cut. So I want to do an across the board tax cut, but it's just not realistic right now.
Source: The Kudlow Report (CNBC)Tags: Budget, Economy, Taxes, Assertion of fact, Specific policy point or details
Meg Whitman
/
May 18, 2010Hugh Hewitt: We have talked many times, but I want to make sure people understand this. You have ruled out tax increases as a solution. Meg Whitman: Correct. Absolutely correct. We cannot increase taxes on Californians. In fact, I want to reduce some taxes to get employers hiring again.
Source: Hugh Hewitt ShowTags: Taxes, Promise, Specific policy point or details
Meg Whitman
/
April 15, 2010Increase the research & development tax credit for California businesses from 15 percent to 20 percent to promote investment in new technologies and industries of the future. This will fuel innovation and keep California on the cutting edge of the global economy.
Source:Tags: Business, Taxes, Specific policy point or details
Meg Whitman
/
April 15, 2010Provide several targeted tax incentives: an incentive to encourage businesses to locate around our universities and foster close collaborations; a tax credit to create green tech jobs; and a $10,000 tax credit for buyers of new and existing homes. This last tax credit will shore up our real estate industry, increase home values and make it easier for young families to purchase their first homes.
Source:Tags: Business, Taxes, Specific policy point or details
Meg Whitman
/
April 15, 2010As California's economy recovers and spending has been brought under control, I will move ahead with across-the-board income tax cuts.
Source:Tags: Taxes, Specific policy point or details



